Stories by Storie

Everyone has a story to tell. What is yours?

  • Stories by Storie
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
    • Book Activities
    • Book Lists by Topic
    • Classroom Management
    • Freebies
    • Math
    • Reading Tips
  • Free
  • Shop
    • Teachers Pay Teachers
    • Amazon
    • Bookshop
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

Building Mathematical Comprehension – Chapter 4

June 29, 2013

Before I get started, just a few quick reminders:
 
 
Math Game Markdown – tomorrow is the last day to purchase my math games at a discounted price.  The games are marked down anywhere from 20 – 33% off.  Check them out by clicking the picture:
 
Have you entered for a chance to win a new pencil sharpener from Classroom Friendly Supplies?  This one also ends tomorrow.  Click the picture below to enter:
 
Now, back to our regularly scheduled programming, er…blog post 🙂
 
Chapter 4 – Increasing Comprehension by Asking Questions
 
Keene and Zimmerman write, “Questions lead children through the discovery of their world.”
 
One of my favorite things about teaching young students is their insatiable curiosity.  I love when they pose a question that really drives instruction.  However, I have to admit that sometimes we can’t let the questions drive our instruction because of the pressure to meet the standards with the little time we are given.
 
 
McGregor and Gelb came to these realizations about math:
* Teachers can encourage kids to build on their natural curiosity by asking questions.
 
* The ability to ask questions can be developed.
 
* Sometimes there is no need for answers.  In fact, sometimes there are no answers.
 
* Teachers should believe that the questions they ask influence the depth and quality of our teaching.
 
* It may be more important to find the right question than to find the right answer.
 
 
Students need to understand how mathematicians use questioning to increase comprehension:
1. Mathematicians purposefully and spontaneously ask questions before, during, and after working with mathematical concepts or problems.
 
2. Mathematicians ask questions for many reasons.
 
3. Mathematicians understand that there may be more than one answer to a question.  they do not stop thinking about a question after they discover one right answer.
 
4. Mathematicians understand that many intriguing questions require further information or explanation.
 
5. Mathematicians understand that hearing the questions of others inspires new questions of their own.  Listening to the answers of others can inspire new thinking.
 
 
Just like in reading, there are different types of questions: Right There, Think and Search, On My Own, and Thick & Thin Questions.
 
Right There – the answers are literal and easy to find.
 
Think and Search – the answers are in the text, but are harder to find because students have to put together more than one sentence to get the answer.
 
On My Own – the answers are not directly in the text.  Students have to think about the text and what they already know to get the answer.
 
Thick Questions – answers are long and require further thinking.  The questions often start with Why? How Come? I Wonder…
 
Thin Questions – can be answered with a yes, no, or a number.  They are the more literal questions.
 
 
Thinking stems to help get students to question:
* I wonder…
* Why does…
* What would happen if…
* How is this similar to…
* I don’t understand…
* What other information is needed…
* What does this remind me of…
* What do I notice about…
* Are there any patterns…
* What strategies might I…
* What do I need to find out….
* Will diagrams, models, or other representations help me… 
 
 
Here are some resources I found that I think go right along with this chapter.  First, I saw this on Pinterest and it leads to a free download from TpT:
source: Meg Anderson
 
 
Next, I found two documents with more information about questioning:
 
Building Capacity Series: 8 Tips for Asking Effective Questions in Math
 
Promoting Mathematical Thinking and Discussion with Effective Questioning Strategies
 
 
Oh, and make sure you check out these other posts about the chapter.  Some of these posts include freebies for you:
 

Coming Soon: Chapter 5 – The Importance of Visualizing Mathematical Ideas
signature

Related posts:

No related posts.

«
»

Filed Under: math Leave a Comment

Comments

  1. Pam says

    June 30, 2013 at 12:04 am

    Thanks for sharing the links. Some interesting reads.

    Reply
  2. Brenda says

    July 5, 2013 at 3:59 am

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this chapter, Storie!

    Brenda
    Primary Inspired

    Reply
  3. Beth says

    July 9, 2013 at 12:56 am

    Yeah!!! The Building Capacity Series is from Ontario…my province. I've looked at it during Math PD before but forgot it until now, so thanks.
    Great post too.
    Beth
    Thinking of Teaching

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe Via Email

Search

Categories

Latest on Instagram

A new month means new books to fill the shelf. Her A new month means new books to fill the shelf. Here’s what we have on display right now. We still haven’t seen any snow ❄️, but we plan to curl up and read all about it. Maybe that will help! Do you spy some of your winter favorites? ⁣
⁣
#winterbookshelf⁣
#seasonalbookshelf⁣
#januarybookshelf⁣
Happy New Year! 🎉⁣ ⁣ If you’re starting 2 Happy New Year! 🎉⁣
⁣
If you’re starting 2021 by making resolutions and setting goals with your students, I suggest sharing Squirrel’s New Year’s Resolution by Pat Miller. This book follows Squirrel around the forest as she learns what a resolution is and helps her friends get started on theirs. Swipe to see a kid craft you can pair with this story. I also have comprehension and vocabulary activities for this book. Just follow the link in my bio for more information.⁣
⁣
#squirrelsnewyearsresolution
As 2020 comes to an end, it has been fun to look b As 2020 comes to an end, it has been fun to look back at all of the books I’ve shared this year. It was so hard to narrow it down to a Top 9 list, so you’re getting 20 instead. Do you see some of your favorites?⁣
⁣
⁣
⁣
⁣
⁣
⁣
#raisingreaders #bookshare #bookpusher #classroombookaday #picturebooks #picturebookaddict #bookstagram #storiesbystorie #readersofinstagram #kidsbookswelove #kidlit #readalouds #iteach2nd #teachermom #picturebooksofinstagram #childrensbooks
Winter is officially here! Have you had snow yet w Winter is officially here! Have you had snow yet where you live? We haven’t, but my kids are anxiously waiting. While we wait, it’s been fun to revisit our favorite snow day memories while reading Ten Ways to Hear Snow.⁣
⁣
In this story, Lina wakes up to a blanket of snow outside,  but she is supposed to help her grandma cook that day. Since Sitta is losing her eyesight, Lina rushes to bundle up and get over to her home. Lina wants to make sure her grandma is okay and knows about the snow outside. On the way, Lina explores the city muffled by snow and discovers ten different ways to hear snow. ❄️⁣
⁣
What is your favorite (or least favorite) thing about snow?⁣
⁣
#tenwaystohearsnow⁣
#winterpicturebooks⁣
#booksaboutsnow⁣
#snowbooksforkids⁣
#winterbooksforkids⁣
#cathycamper⁣
#kenardpak⁣
@kokilabooks⁣
@kenardpak⁣
@cfastwolf ⁣
@penguinkids
If you could make a wish on a snow globe, what wou If you could make a wish on a snow globe, what would you wish for? ⁣
⁣
During one of the worst snow storms of the year, a little girl and her family settle in for the night. They build a fort by the fire and enjoy a picnic-style dinner. Later that night, the little girl makes a wish on her snow globe. The next morning the family wakes up to a winter wonderland outside. ⁣
⁣
“What if, ⁣
dear friends, ⁣
on this snow globe day⁣
EVERYONE comes out to play?”⁣
⁣
Snow Globe Wishes has a great message about slowing down, enjoying the simple things, and bringing a community together. It would be perfect to share while getting cozy on cold, winter day!⁣
⁣
⁣
#snowglobewishes⁣
#winterpicturebooks⁣
#childrensbooks⁣
#kidlit⁣
#readingismagic⁣
#picturebooksaremyjam⁣
#picturebooksofinstagram⁣
@sleepingbearpress⁣
If you’ve been around here for awhile, you’re If you’ve been around here for awhile, you’re probably a big fan of books. Whether you’re shopping for the holidays, a birthday, or celebrating a milestone, books make great gifts. If you still need convincing (or justifying your recent book purchases 😉), I recently shared 10 reasons why books make the best gifts on my blog. Follow the link in my bio.
Danny’s back in an all-new adventure!⁣ ⁣ In Danny’s back in an all-new adventure!⁣
⁣
In this latest book, Danny’s headed to the water park with his family. Throughout the day, he’s faced with a lot of important decisions to make. Will he be fair and kind, show empathy towards others, keep himself safe, and take responsibility for his actions? That’s up to the reader to help Danny decide! ⁣
⁣
Growing up, I loved reading choose-your-own-adventure books because it was so much fun getting to decide how the story ended. Now my own kids get to experience that same reading magic with these Power to Choose books from Ganit and Adir Levy. My kids are bound and determined to read every single one of the 9 different endings.⁣
⁣
Have you read any of the Danny or Darla books yet? If so, do you have a favorite?⁣
⁣
⁣
#whatshoulddannydo⁣
#whatshoulddannydoonvacation⁣
#thepowertochoose⁣
@ganitandadir 
#raisingreaders⁣
#picturebooksforkids⁣
#bookpusher⁣
#clasroombookaday⁣
#kidsbookstagram

Copyright © 2021 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs